A priori performance measures for arc-based formulations of the Vehicle Routing Problem∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
The Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is a central problem for many transportation applications, and although it is well known that it is difficult to solve, how much of this difficulty is due to the formulation of the problem is less understood. In this paper we experimentally investigate how the solution times to solve a VRP with a general IP solver are affected by the formulation of the VRP used. The different formulations are evaluated by examining solution efficiency as a function of several a priori performance measures based on the data parameters. Our experimental results show how the solution run times are sensitive to problem parameters; in particular the sensitivity of formulations to the coefficient of variation of the cost matrix of travel times is explained by two interacting factors. ∗Research supported by NSF under grant CMS-0409887 †Corresponding author
منابع مشابه
A PFIH-Based Heuristic for Green Routing Problem with Hard Time Windows
Transportation sector generates a considerable part of each nation's gross domestic product and considered among the largest consumers of oil products in the world. This paper proposes a heuristic method for the vehicle routing problem with hard time windows while incorporating the costs of fuel, driver, and vehicle. The proposed heuristic uses a novel speed optimization algorithm to reach its ...
متن کاملModel and Solution Approach for Multi objective-multi commodity Capacitated Arc Routing Problem with Fuzzy Demand
The capacitated arc routing problem (CARP) is one of the most important routing problems with many applications in real world situations. In some real applications such as urban waste collection and etc., decision makers have to consider more than one objective and investigate the problem under uncertain situations where required edges have demand for more than one type of commodity. So, in thi...
متن کاملA novel heuristic algorithm for capacitated vehicle routing problem
The vehicle routing problem with the capacity constraints was considered in this paper. It is quite difficult to achieve an optimal solution with traditional optimization methods by reason of the high computational complexity for large-scale problems. Consequently, new heuristic or metaheuristic approaches have been developed to solve this problem. In this paper, we constructed a new heuristic ...
متن کاملA time-dependent vehicle routing problem for disaster response phase in multi-graph-based network
Logistics planning in disaster response phase involves dispatching commodities such as medical materials, personnel, food, etc. to affected areas as soon as possible to accelerate the relief operations. Since transportation vehicles in disaster situations can be considered as scarce resources, thus, the efficient usage of them is substantially important. In this study, we provide a dynamic vehi...
متن کاملSupply Chain Scheduling Using a Transportation System Composed of Vehicle Routing Problem and Cross-Docking Approaches
This study considers a combination of cross-docking and vehicle routing problem (VRP) approachesto transport raw material and parts in a supply chain. The supply chain is composed of some supplierswhich are spread in different geographical zones and multiple shared vehicles with different speedsand capacities for transporting orders from the suppliers to a manufacturer. After ...
متن کامل